Login »

Michael Dale

Search Posts

Categories

Bluetrait
        Bluetrait
            Coding
            Geek
            General
            Coding
                PHP
                Bluetrait
                WordPress
                    Plugins
                PHP
                Bluetrait (Program)
            Geek
                Juniper
                Cisco
                IBM N2200 8363
                PCs
                Spam
                IPv6
                Apple
                NetScreen
                Internet
            General
                Uni

Click here if you are looking for Bluetrait, the weblog software.


Login

Username:

Password:

Should other peoples comments effect yours?

Posted by Michael Dale on Mon, 27 Sep 2004 9:53 PM

Okay, So you've just read this large post on some blog site and you're about to reply. But wait, there are comments from other people too! Now should what these people have written effect your response?
You've pretty much made up your mind about what you're going to say before hand.

But what if what you're about to say has already been said? Should you be silenced!? Comments are good for feedback on a topic, but are they there for discussion? I don't know.

Should my comments link go to the first comment or straight to the comment post field? Should people read the other comments first?

A good example is here: http://mezzoblue.com/ The comments are very muchly separated from the post. You must click to read the comments. Good or Bad?